Wednesday, February 1, 2023
DLTEMPIRE
  • Home
  • News
  • Blockchain
  • Ethereum
  • BNB
  • Binance
  • Luna Crash
  • Crypto Mining
  • DeFi
  • ICO
  • Regulation
  • Top 10 coins
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
  • Blockchain
  • Ethereum
  • BNB
  • Binance
  • Luna Crash
  • Crypto Mining
  • DeFi
  • ICO
  • Regulation
  • Top 10 coins
No Result
View All Result
DLTEMPIRE
No Result
View All Result
Home Regulation

Let Congress decide who gets to regulate crypto

Lucinda Keatinge by Lucinda Keatinge
September 10, 2022
in Regulation
0
Let Congress decide who gets to regulate crypto
0
SHARES
0
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter


Turf battles are nothing new in Washington, but the one currently raging over which federal agency has authority to regulate the trading of digital assets reveals deep dysfunction in the modern administrative state. The battle goes far beyond which agency gets more power; the future of the internet may be at stake.

The United States is somewhat unusual in having different agencies to regulate securities, like stocks and bonds, and derivatives, like options, swaps, and commodity futures. The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) is the regulator of the former, while the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) regulates the latter. But the jurisdictional borders are sometimes murky, thanks to overlapping mandates between the agencies, as well as with other state and federal financial regulators.  

Division of labor and competition may offer some benefits, but in this case, the lack of a clear regulator has meant that digital assets have fallen into some jurisdictional cracks. The 60 million Americans who trade crypto assets do so either overseas, at the mercy of foreign law, or under state money-transfer laws designed for payday lending, not financial markets.

It turns out that which agency has jurisdiction matters a lot. While the SEC regulates through detailed rules, the CFTC more often employs a principles-based approach. The former offers certainty and rigidity, while the latter provides greater flexibility. While strict SEC enforcement might limit downside risk, the CFTC model is more likely to encourage investment in innovation. 

These differing approaches also are reflected in how the agencies have approached emerging markets for digital assets. CFTC-registered exchanges have been approved to offer Bitcoin derivatives products for several years now. Indeed, the CFTC has a history of fostering and regulating financial innovations. Although originally tasked with overseeing plain-vanilla hedges on agricultural commodities, the CFTC has used its broad, principles-based approach to permit countless new derivatives on everything from interest rates to the weather. 

Meanwhile, SEC staff have sat on numerous crypto exchange-traded-fund (ETF) registrations and the commission has repeatedly rejected proposals by firms to list a Bitcoin ETF product. In fact, the commission has largely chosen to regulate crypto through enforcement actions against entities it accuses of offering “unregistered crypto asset securities.” This has led to some bizarre outcomes. One project might blast ahead without consulting the SEC, raise billions of dollars, and ultimately pay only a small fine to the commission, while other projects actively seek SEC guidance prior to launch and are met with staff silence and stares, thus never getting to the starting blocks.

The SEC and CFTC have had fights about jurisdiction before. When futures on stock-market indices flourished in the late 1970s, the agencies signed the Shad-Johnson Accord, which gave each agency a bit of the action. The accord ultimately found its way into law a few years later, which is as it should be. Congress, not agencies, should determine jurisdiction.

Which is precisely what recently introduced bipartisan legislation—sponsored by Senate Agriculture Committee Chair Debbie Stabenow (D-Mich.) and Ranking Member John Boozman (R-Ark.), along with Sens. Cory Booker (D-N.J.) and John Thune (R-S.D.)—seeks to do. The Digital Commodities Consumer Protection Act of 2022 would define cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin and Ethereum as “digital commodities” subject to CFTC jurisdiction. 

The logic is sound. Bitcoin, Ethereum, and most other crypto projects do not have managers, looking more like currencies or gold, which are not under SEC authority. If, however, companies issue digital “tokens” that grant the same rights and obligations to “tokenholders” that normally would pass to stockholders, then the SEC would have jurisdiction. Simply calling a stock by some other name ought not make it immune from securities regulation.

Critics of the bill argue that the SEC is the tougher cop, but it is ill-suited to encourage financial innovation. Some standards and regulations are needed to onshore investment and to protect investors, but entrepreneurs and investors cannot be left to worry that regulators may come knocking one day and claim that they’ve been violating securities laws all this time. The CFTC is the right agency to deliver on sensible regulation that balances the needs of investor protection with regulatory discretion to encourage innovation.


This Patriot Day, honor 9/11 victims by serving America


America needs a strategic partnership with Uzbekistan

Crypto is in its infancy. The claims that blockchain technology will offer alternatives to government currencies, enable peer-to-peer investing, reduce transaction costs throughout the financial system, and even create a better Internet remain speculative, at this point. But the potential is there, and companies are investing billions. There will be winners and losers, and hopefully breakthroughs. 

A robust trading system in the United States is essential to ensuring good ideas get funded, while fraudsters are deterred and punished. If Web 3.0 and other blockchain-based technologies are to come from American entrepreneurs and enrich American investors, crypto markets and investors need regulatory certainty. 

Geoffrey A. Manne is the president and founder of the International Center for Law & Economics (ICLE). M. Todd Henderson is the Michael J. Marks Professor of Law at the University of Chicago Law School and an ICLE academic affiliate. 



Source link

Tags: CongressCryptodecideregulate
Previous Post

Here’s Why Terra Classic (LUNC) Pumped Over 400% This Month

Next Post

Getting Mighty Defensive For This Season

Lucinda Keatinge

Lucinda Keatinge

Next Post
Getting Mighty Defensive For This Season

Getting Mighty Defensive For This Season

  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
Veteran pilot killed in vintage airplane crash in Kern County

Veteran pilot killed in vintage airplane crash in Kern County

September 3, 2022
Wells Fargo Mentioned Ripple (XRP) As A Digital Currency In August Report

Wells Fargo Mentioned Ripple (XRP) As A Digital Currency In August Report

August 16, 2022
Sold Out Presale Creating Huge Interest In Gnox (GNOX) From Binance Coin (BNB) And PancakeSwap (CAKE) Holders

Sold Out Presale Creating Huge Interest In Gnox (GNOX) From Binance Coin (BNB) And PancakeSwap (CAKE) Holders

August 16, 2022
Best Coins To Buy On PancakeSwap App In August 2022

Best Coins To Buy On PancakeSwap App In August 2022

August 12, 2022
How the Stance of World’s Top Crypto Exchange Could Impact Possibility of Future Ethereum Forks

How the Stance of World’s Top Crypto Exchange Could Impact Possibility of Future Ethereum Forks

0
Binance, Mastercard launch prepaid card in Argentina to bridge cryptocurrencies, everyday purchases

Binance, Mastercard launch prepaid card in Argentina to bridge cryptocurrencies, everyday purchases

0
What is Alpaca Finance? – Asia Crypto Today

What is Alpaca Finance? – Asia Crypto Today

0
Blockchain ETF’s Top Holding Has Been a Strong Outperformer

Blockchain ETF’s Top Holding Has Been a Strong Outperformer

0
A New digital currency that enables Private Permissionless Payments on Blockchain

A New digital currency that enables Private Permissionless Payments on Blockchain

February 1, 2023
Provident in Massachusetts pushing past crypto woes

Provident in Massachusetts pushing past crypto woes

February 1, 2023
Bitcoin, Ethereum, and Equity Markets Drop as Fed Likely to Hike … – The Coin Republic

Bitcoin, Ethereum, and Equity Markets Drop as Fed Likely to Hike … – The Coin Republic

February 1, 2023
BNB Bowl 2023 lineup (Pain of Truth, Death Threat, Bulldoze, Merauder, End It, All Out War & more)

BNB Bowl 2023 lineup (Pain of Truth, Death Threat, Bulldoze, Merauder, End It, All Out War & more)

February 1, 2023

Recent News

A New digital currency that enables Private Permissionless Payments on Blockchain

A New digital currency that enables Private Permissionless Payments on Blockchain

February 1, 2023
Provident in Massachusetts pushing past crypto woes

Provident in Massachusetts pushing past crypto woes

February 1, 2023
Bitcoin, Ethereum, and Equity Markets Drop as Fed Likely to Hike … – The Coin Republic

Bitcoin, Ethereum, and Equity Markets Drop as Fed Likely to Hike … – The Coin Republic

February 1, 2023
BNB Bowl 2023 lineup (Pain of Truth, Death Threat, Bulldoze, Merauder, End It, All Out War & more)

BNB Bowl 2023 lineup (Pain of Truth, Death Threat, Bulldoze, Merauder, End It, All Out War & more)

February 1, 2023

Recent News

A New digital currency that enables Private Permissionless Payments on Blockchain

A New digital currency that enables Private Permissionless Payments on Blockchain

February 1, 2023
Provident in Massachusetts pushing past crypto woes

Provident in Massachusetts pushing past crypto woes

February 1, 2023

Categories

  • Altcoin
  • Artificial Intelligence
  • Binance
  • Blockchain
  • BNB
  • Business
  • Crypto Mining
  • DeFi
  • Education
  • Ethereum
  • Featured
  • ICO
  • Luna Crash
  • Metaverse
  • News
  • Regulation
  • Top 10 coins
  • Uncategorized

Follow Us

Follow Us

Find Via Tags

Big Binance Bitcoin Blockchain BNB BTC Buy Cardano CEO Chain Coin CoinDesk Coins crash Crypto Cryptocurrency DeFi Digital Dogecoin ETH Ethereum Exchange eyes Finance FTX Heres Investors latest LUNA Market Merge Million mining Network News NFT Prediction Price Protocol Regulation Solana Token Top Tweet Week

© 2021 Dltempire

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
  • Blockchain
  • Ethereum
  • BNB
  • Binance
  • Luna Crash
  • Crypto Mining
  • DeFi
  • ICO
  • Regulation
  • Top 10 coins

© 2021 Dltempire